Skip to main content

Gym myths: The fitness foods stalling your progress.

Eating for your goals.

We all know what fitness people eat. If you are at all interested in sport or fitness you are undoubtedly being bombarded with adverts for "performance foods". Shakes, bars, teas, all kinds of stuff.

And you could be totally forgiven for thinking that including these in your diet means faster fat loss, better performance etc. So it's very disappointing when this doesn't happen.

Why are some foods and supplements, like protein shakes, so cool, when others, like a tin of fish are completely overlooked?

Let's break down my top overrated fitness foods....

Peanut butter.

Peanut butter in itself isn't a terrible food choice. The decent ones aren't heavily processed (go for the ones that are just nuts, no sugar and oil added). But there is one thing about peanut butter which is overlooked....


Bodybuilders and some strength athletes eat a lot of peanut butter *when bulking*. Its purpose is to provide an easy to eat, easy to digest, CALORIE DENSE food option. If you are a naturally skinny guy and you want to put on some serious mass, you need to consume some serious calories (check this video to see how Alan Thrall does it). This involves eating until you're pretty uncomfortable, so any way to make that easier by consuming lots of calories in small mouthfuls, as liquid/paste etc is a good call.

Bodybuilders look lean and ripped on stage, but what you don't see is that in their off season, they are a little fluffier. You need to eat excess calories to build new muscle, an inevitable consequence of this is that you gain fat. That's cool, because part of the training cycle of a body builder is to lose that fat in the run up to a competition. But if you aren't a physique competitor, this kind of bulk-cut cycle is a psychological and physical strain you don't need.

If you are training to be healthy, fitter, gain a bit more muscle, maybe lose some weight, you have no need to shovel down max calories, and consuming a large amount of calories as fat, in a foodstuff which your body will barely notice isn't going to help you reach your goals.

A 10g serving of peanut butter contains 5g of fat, 2.5g of protein and about 60 calories.

To get a full "serving" of protein you are going to need to eat 100g of peanut butter, which is about 600 calories and a very cloying mouth feel.

Alternate: Eat a small portion (1-2 thumbs) of mixed nuts.

Energy gels 

I popped into a bike shop last week and saw an enormous display of energy gels. I'm seeing them turn up more and more lately.

Energy gels are basically sugar in an easy to consume form. They were intended for endurance athletes like long distance cyclists and marathon runners, because eating during a race is tricky and racing without eating is also tricky.

But you'll get through zumba just fine without them.

In their place gels are probably very useful, but they are heavily marketed to "general population", because the market is small when you restrict it to just the elite athletes they were created for.

In fact many endurance athletes are spurning them for alternates, because they cause stomach upsets and they are finding better options to keep them going.

Not everyone needs to eat during a workout. If you are training for more than 90 minutes straight, you might consider it. There's a lot of cheaper, easier digestible options. Learning to eat while exercising is also a skill, so if you are training for endurance, expect it to feel a bit odd at first.

Sports drinks are also made for this purpose, but you can mix your own electrolyte/sugar combo with less additives.

If you are training for strength, you may find yourself needing a hit of sugar during your heaviest sets. I'm talking singles and doubles close to your max - this is because the hit of adrenaline from intense effort can mess with your blood sugar and make you feel faint. In the 2 weeks when I am peaking for competition, I do eat between sets, but I tend to go for a jelly baby - because I like them and the little row of jelly babies awaiting their fate amuses me. Again a sports drink is a reasonable option.

Take home message - unless you are training very long or very hard, you can probably wait until after your workout for a snack.

Alternative: Have a banana


When protein shakes aren't extra enough for you.

BCAAs and EEAs are basically very refined protein. They contain just the stuff you most need. As you might imagine this involves a fair amount of processing and they cost money to buy.

But... here's the kicker... there is little valid evidence that they have any effect on performance. 

There is nothing in them which you cannot get by eating an appropriate amount of complete proteins from healthy food sources. And if you aren't doing that, you need to look at your diet, not your supps dealer. 

There may be some times that these are relevant for a small population, but most of the time you're just making your pee more expensive.

Alternative: Eat 1-2 palms of a protein rich food source with every meal. If you are a vegetarian be sure to include complete or complementary proteins.


I love a smoothie, but you'd feel more satisfied from your breakfast and get slightly better nutrition/fibre content if you just ate the fruit and veg.

Unless it's kale, in which case blend ahead. No one wants to eat that.

Smoothies are often marketed as a healthy drink, check out all those vitamins and stuff... and it's green! And it's got goji berries and we all know that anything with goji berries is magic!

But a  smoothie isn't a drink. It's a snack, or even a meal. An easy and convenient way to consume a lot of easily digested sugar with not-so-much of the stuff that nature usually packages them in.

That said, I am a massive fan of the Super Shake, for anyone who struggles to get a decent, balanced breakfast in, or who needs a substantial snack. This will provide you with a portion of protein, a portion of veg and about 400 calories. I like them for "first breakfast" when I know I won't be able to prepare or eat anything substantial until later. Or as a pre-workout meal in the car if I am going straight from work to the gym.

Alternative: Eat the fruit, mixed into the yoghurt. Delicious.

Protein candy bars.

Who doesn't love a protein Snickers? No one. Except people with nut allergies.

How smug does it feel to eat a chocolate bar and be all like "ooh, but this is a *protein* bar, I can feel the gains".

Hang on there sunshine. You are eating a chocolate bar. Albeit one with a bit of extra protein which may well help you hit your macro goals.

You are still consuming the calories of a regular chocolate bar, and you are still consuming a highly processed foodstuff. Stop pretending it's a celery stick.

If you were planning on eating a chocolate bar anyway, then there's nothing wrong with choosing a high protein alternative, especially if you are trying to raise your protein levels. Just don't kid yourself that it's a "healthy snack", or that it's going to help you manage your weight. 

I coach my nutrition clients to start where they are at, and look for small, positive changes. A supershake instead of a large premade smoothie, or a protein bar instead of a chocolate bar may well be that small change. And that's just cool, so long as we are mindful of the reality of the situation.

Alternative: There's lots of options for high protein snacks, like jerky, boiled eggs, a tin of fish, a protein shake....

So much of the stuff athletes eat...

I do my best deadlift sessions on coffee and doughnuts. Does this mean doughnuts are an excellent health choice for even pursuer of fitness. Clearly not.

I would expect most people who saw me eating a doughnut outside the gym to ask "why are you eating that, does that actually help?"

And I would say "why yes, imaginary and curious stranger, it is providing me with a fast hit of carbs which I am going to need to stop me passing out between these stupidly heavy lifts with which I am about to abuse my central nervous system".

I'm not doing it for "health", a lot of the things athletes do for performance are contrary to good health. I'm certainly not doing it for weight management!

Be curious. Don't just accept that something is a healthy choice *for you* because you see healthy people consuming them, or because someone tells you so. Ask why. What is it that this foodstuff is offering me, and does that align with what *I* want out of my nutrition? Will it support *my* training? And most of all, Is there a better, cheaper, healthier or easier alternative?

Liked this? Interested in what I can do to help you on a healthy track to your fitness goals? You can start out with my completely FREE reset, by signing up to my mailing list. In this 7 day programme I take you through some of the most important changes you can make to your lifestyle, to make you feel better, through building healthy habits into your lifestyle.


Popular posts from this blog

Managing Fibromyalgia flares

I've written before about living with EDS and Fibromyalgia ,  much of my personal fitness and health practices are geared around managing those conditions and keeping me as well as I can be. When managing a chronic health condition, particularly one that involves fatigue and potential flare ups, pacing, good nutrition, good sleep and generally taking care of yourself is always the first priority. Ideally we want to have as few flares as possible. But sometimes they still happen, and when they do, it's good to have a strategy in place. And I'm going to be talking in fairly general terms, because while EDS and Fibro are my personal experience, there is so little understanding of the mechanisms behind these conditions, that most strategies are going to be applicable to a number of conditions where crashes of exhaustion and pain are a feature. So what is a flare? A flare is a period where someone with chronic illness suffers increased symptoms for a short while. The

Step away from the scale. Why weigh ins and weight loss don't match.

I have a persistant bugbear when it comes to health coaching, and it's this issue of "weight". People are often talking about "losing weight", the number on the scale becomes a focus. "If only I could just get under 65kg" they say. Or worse I see advertised "buy this supplement and you can lose 20kg in a fortnight". I've found myself frequently sitting with a weight-focussed client and asking "if you were 2 dress sizes smaller, fit and toned, but you weighed the same as you do now, could you be happy with that?" You might be surprised how challenging a question that can be. For many people, particularly those who have struggled with weight loss, that number is the absolute key. They can wake up, feeling energised and full of life, slip into those jeans that used to live hopefully in the bottom of the drawer, check themselves in the mirror and love what they see... then they step on the scales, see the number is half a kilo

Is being polite sabotaging your weight loss?

I've been thinking a lot lately about the barriers that make it hard for people to stick to healthy habits, or even take them up in the first place. My personal training clients are a lovely bunch, and one thing I can certainly say is that none of them have come to me completely uninformed about healthy eating. Most people have done some homework before they get to the point of hiring me, and while I always go over the basics (never assume anything) I know that when I tell them stuff like this, it's not new information to them: Eat less to lose weight Eat protein with every meal Eat 5 portions of fruit and veg a day Consume high sugar and fat treats rarely and in moderate portions Drink water with every meal or snack Exercise regularly That's not rocket science, so why are so many people still struggling with it? Is it because "the rules" are more complicated? Are they missing the "weird trick" (spoiler alert, there are no weird tricks

My top apps for supporting a healthy lifestyle.

The hardest part of making healthy choices and lifestyle changes is making it a habit. It's easy to make a decision to "eat better", "exercise more" or whatever your current plan is. It's a lot harder to stick to it on the rough days, for long enough that it becomes a habit and part of your life that you can't imagine being without. I love a bit of tech. I am a super geeky science nerd and finding ways to use technology to support my health and fitness makes me very happy. So with this in mind I thought I'd give a quick run down of my favourite smartphone apps for developing and maintaining healthy habits. Habitica I'm starting with this one because it's mad and I love it. Habitica is basically a to-do list app, but it's specially for the gamers among us. If you are familiar with Dungeons and Dragons, and all the games that grew out of that system and fantasy world, you will recognise Habitica. The app allows you to create 3 t

What's the deal with yoga and hypermobility?

I wanted to address a question today that keeps coming up on various hypermobility and EDS forums that I frequent. It comes up so often in fact that I feel like I have to write this all up in one place, to save me 1000s of key strokes of individual responses and distil some of my opinions and thought processes on the matter. It always goes like this. Someone asks a question like "I've just been diagnosed with hypermobility, I've been told I can't do yoga anymore..." The responses are always a mixture of "yes, my doctor/physio told me yoga was the worst thing I could do for my hypermobility" and "I do yoga and it's been the best thing for my hypermobility". So what gives? Well, I'm firmly in the "yoga is useful" camp, and I have to disclose that. I'm a yoga practitioner of around 20 years and a perinatal yoga teacher , as well as a personal trainer and bendy person. While I have the deepest respect for the medic