Skip to main content

What's the deal with yoga and hypermobility?

I wanted to address a question today that keeps coming up on various hypermobility and EDS forums that I frequent. It comes up so often in fact that I feel like I have to write this all up in one place, to save me 1000s of key strokes of individual responses and distil some of my opinions and thought processes on the matter.

It always goes like this. Someone asks a question like "I've just been diagnosed with hypermobility, I've been told I can't do yoga anymore..."

The responses are always a mixture of "yes, my doctor/physio told me yoga was the worst thing I could do for my hypermobility" and "I do yoga and it's been the best thing for my hypermobility".

So what gives?

Well, I'm firmly in the "yoga is useful" camp, and I have to disclose that. I'm a yoga practitioner of around 20 years and a perinatal yoga teacher, as well as a personal trainer and bendy person.

While I have the deepest respect for the medical professionals who are giving out this advice, their expertise doesn't usually extend into yoga, and I think often these comments are coming from a misunderstanding of what yoga is about, how it works and what actually happens to a hypermobile body while training yoga. I'd never suggest that anyone went against the advice of their medical carers, but it is an opportunity to open up a conversation and find out exactly what they are objecting to, and why.

So let's break it down.

There are different kinds of yoga.

Loads. Millions. Many of them are related to each other, in that students of a particular teacher went off and started their own schools which have subtle differences, but some of them are wildly different.

Yoga has been heavily appropriated by the Western world, and in some cases, what originated as a spiritual lifestyle of mind-body connection, has turned into an instagrammable pursuit of "perfect" aesthetics and visually impressive feats. Or it has been modified to fit Western fitness ideals of physical challenge, sweatiness and feats of strength. If that's your bag, then that's absolutely fine - we should all be doing the exercise we love most.

But I've also encountered hypermobile people (or zebras) who have been to one of these "high performance" yoga classes and found it wholly unsuitable. This shouldn't be a reason to write off yoga completely. It just means that teacher or style wasn't right for that person at that time.

The confusion about what yoga is

The primary reason our zebras are being told to stay clear of yoga is "yoga makes you more flexible, you are already too flexible"

This is a classic misunderstanding of the purpose and practice of yoga. Yoga is about building healthy function and movement patterns into the body, in a mindful way. It's about tuning into what your body is capable of, and what your body needs, right now, without judgement. This is what is lost in the Western picture perfect asana culture. It's not about "achieving" the asana, it's about the journey of figuring out where the imbalance of strength, mobility and alignment is in your body, about acknowledging it and caring for it.

Yoga is also about a lot more than asana. It's about breathing, which improves core strength, cardiovascular and autonomic function (all important for zebras). It's about being aware of your body, it's position, alignment and the changes within it (also super important....) and it's about meditation and relaxation to reduce stressors in the body (the sort of thing that can trigger fatigue, pain and comorbid conditions like fibromyalgia).

Again, if you go to a class and the sole focus is forcing yourself into a human pretzel shape - you are missing out on some of the best bits of yoga, and that's not what I'm talking about when I say yoga is great for hypermobility syndrome.

Yoga for alignment and good movement patterns

Many of the yoga sequences and poses are designed to promote good biomechanics. We practice the movements slowly and mindfully, until they are set into our muscle memory and start creeping out in our everyday movements. The posture, the gait, the process of moving the body, with awareness, balance and core strength, applying the right muscles in the right order with the right balance. It's exactly what people with poor proprioception and unstable joints need.

I've spoken to people who were advised "if you do yoga you must be careful not to extend beyond a healthy range of movement". Well, yes. That is exactly what you will be working on! One of the big problems with being hypermobile, is that we don't have a clear "feeling" of a safe range of motion, by the time a joint reaches the limit of its movement, it has already gone into a position which is potentially unsafe. We do this all the time, when walking, standing, sitting... in our sleep. Yoga practice gives us a window of time to focus purely on getting that right.

Being hypermobile doesn't necessarily mean being bendy everywhere

The most common diagnostic procedure for hypermobility is the Beighton score. It is a measure of how generalised your joint hypermobility is. It's not always accurate because it only covers 9 joints out of dozens that could be affected, it's also not indicative of severity. I know people with EDS who have a score of 4/9 and have severe movement impairment. I have a score of 8/9 and with management I pass as healthy.

When I encounter hypermobile PT clients, I am always fascinated by how their unique bodies come together. The hypermobility is not always bilateral (I have one hypermobile wrist and one "normal" one). Often they will have a large range of motion in an internal hip rotation, but very limited external rotation. Often years of "interesting" posture (standing or sitting) have caused some really unusual chain reactions between joint sites. I used to have one pronated foot and one supernated! Hip instability goes unnoticed and manifests in the knees.

When working on postural correction through strength/fitness training, we think on two sides of the coin, what needs to be stronger, and what is too tight?

So what I am getting at is that even someone with hypermobility will have areas that need to be stretched or otherwise released. Probably moreso than the average person.

One of the cool things about yoga, is that you find those areas in the process of working through the movements, and as you work on those movements, getting deeper into the asana, the right parts are gradually released.

Flexibility vs mobility - the language barrier

Here's a fun factoid. The medical definition of mobility is "the ability of a joint to be moved through its range in different planes."

Notice that describes a passive process. Like the Beighton test, it is about how far the joint can be moved, by an external force.

In fitness we call that flexibility.

In fitness terms, mobility is an active process. Mobility is the ability to move a joint using the appropriate musculature. So for instance doing a floor split, using gravity, could be described as flexibility.

But doing a standing split, in yoga or dance, would be mobility, as you have to use your muscles to raise and hold the leg.

So when I say that yoga (or pilates or suchlike) increases mobility, I am saying that it increases the range of motion through which the joint has strength and stability. What a medical professional hears though, is that it makes the joint less stable by increasing passive range of motion.

Two very different things. The first being something many hypermobile people lack, and need to improve their symptoms, the second being a recipe for dislocations.

So what we have come back to, is the need for communication. Clear dialogue and understanding.

I regularly come across people with hypermobility who have been told they need to retire from their favourite sport, or that no one with their condition should consider yoga, or strength training above very low resistance levels, or running. Yet I have also met numerous hypermobile yogis, powerlifters, crossfitters and marathon runners!

Exercise is good for our bodies. It increases connective tissue strength and develops musculature to support our joints. The top experts in rehab for hypermobility recognise that exercise you enjoy and want to take part in is ultimately more effective than conventional "rehab" if only because you actually do it!

So ask questions, seek second opinions, work with all the right experts to figure out your balance between what you enjoy, what works in your body and what makes you feel at your best.

If you are looking for guidance in your exercise or nutrition for general health and well being, you should click over to my website and see the programmes and personalised training options I offer.


  1. My rheumatologist recommended yoga and thought aerial circus sounded like a great idea too: anything that improves proprioception and core strength! But I think I was very lucky he's the one who diagnosed me: I've met people who were told to avoid moving more than necessary at all, which sounds painful and dangerous!

    1. Yes, the first link in the last paragraph is a really interesting seminar by a physio. She breaks down exactly why not moving is a bad call as it leads to a downward spiral of muscles getting weaker, more injury and less capability to move.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Training with Fibromyalgia - a primer for Fitness Professionals

Fitness and Fibromyalgia
The second of my posts about training clients with chronic illness (the first on EDS is here)

Learning how to achieve fitness in a chronically ill body was first my way of life, and later, my profession; as I train or programme for a number of Personal Training clients. I have EDS and Fibromyalgia (which commonly presents alongside EDS).

While the physiology and mechanisms behind EDS are relatively well understood, at least in terms of recognising the roles collagen plays in our bodies and the effects of an anomaly, fibromyalgia is a bit of a tricky one. The diagnosis, causes and management of fibromyalgia are not very well understood, and while progress is being made in terms of recognising physiological markers etc, we are still very much in the dark.

One thing that is generally agreed on however, is that exercise is good therapy for fibromyalgia, and that's where we come in.

Scope of practice
Here we go again...

Fitness professionals are there to help …

Training Ehlers Danlos Athletes - a primer for the Fitpro.

When you have a rare health condition, it's pretty exciting when you encounter someone who knows about it. Even more so when you encounter people who are interested in it and more importantly, understanding how to bridge the gap and work with it.

This is why I am really happy to be seeing more and more fitness professionals asking "I have a client with Ehlers Danlos Syndrome, what do I need to know?"

As a fitpro, and athlete living with Ehlers Danlos Syndrome I am always happy to chat to trainers looking to broaden their understanding, and as I am often answering the same questions, I thought it would be good to do a write up.

Quick disclaimer before we start - I'm not a medic, and this is not for medics. I'm going to provide you with as many references as I can, but please seek specific medical input from your/your client's health care professionals. And with that we get to our first point.

Scope of practice.
Quick, check your job title. Are you a personal tr…

But how can you be an athlete when you are sick?

Training through chronic illness - living life on the edge.
I'm living a double life.

My superhero persona goes to the gym and lifts enormous weights. She's vital and has her life together. Endless to-do lists in a bullet journal, juggling work and kids and being an athlete and performer with theatrical effortlessness.

Then there's the secret side people don't see, where I lie on the sofa in my flare day leggings and fleece, clutching a cup of tea for the slight relief the warmth affords my stiff, clawed hands.

I know I'm not the only one. I know a lot of athletes living with chronic illness. Outwardly fitter and busier than the average person, inwardly wracked with pain and fatigue.

There are two ways people tend to interpret this. Either we are not as sick as we claim, or we are stupidly putting our health at risk doing sport that seems counter-intuitive to our well being. The reality is a lot more complicated. I wanted to formulate a decent answer to "why …

Step away from the New Year weight loss.

I was helping my son get ready for school this week, and we discovered that his school trousers would no longer do up.

"Oooh, looks like you've done some growing in the holiday!" I said, to which he retorted;

"Well, yeah... it IS 2019"

Of course. Silly me. How could I not have considered that.

On reflection I realised that this is exactly what I would like to say to most people who come to me concerned about festive weight gain.

Why the New Year Diet?
There's two types of New Year dieters.

The first type had resolved to get on a new health kick, to address some unhealthy habits or lose a bit of weight, probably before Christmas. But they left it until New Year, because that's a nice milestone to work with and starting a new regime in the chaos of the holidays is just asking for trouble - it's easier to build routine and discipline when things have calmed down a bit.

The others have gained weight over the holidays, and are now worrying about losing i…

Fitness goals for women...

...That don't involve getting smaller.
I've been thinking about body positive personal training again (OK, you got me, I never stopped...)

Specifically because Lift the Bar (a CPD provider for fitness professionals) brought it up recently.

It brought me back particularly to goal setting.

Goal setting for women.
It's often assumed that the reason a woman takes up any kind of "fitness" is to lose weight "tone up", get rid of a body part or otherwise alter the look of her body to one that is normatively considered correct for a women.

Often women turn up at a facility and have goals of this type thrust upon them, because that's got to be why they are there, right?

But more and more, it's not. Plenty of women are fed up with people telling them to get smaller, and whether you are one of those women, or someone trying to help those women, I'm going to throw you a primer.

Not sure what your new goal should be? Not sure what to offer a client who …